The library
Rendered from docs/specs/2026-09-25_software-only-rescope-audit.md; the markdown file is the record.
Scorecard
| Dimension | Grade | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| Plan adherence | Excellent | Contract, documentation rescope, MP4 fixture, and consistency checks match the amended run spec. |
| Scope discipline | Excellent | Changes remain within the declared scope and documented hygiene exceptions. |
| Test coverage | Acceptable | Independently verified 109 tests and clean lint; full-suite rerun blocked by read-only permissions. |
| Review compliance | Excellent | Codex findings addressed through implementation, revised planning constraints, or documented deferrals. |
| Freeze integrity | — | Skipped: no P1/P2/P3 hashes found. |
| Regression check | Acceptable | No failures in executed checks; full regression verification remains limited. TSV blocker is documented. |
| Documentation | Acceptable | Declared updates and AI disclosures present; recorded test counts precede the final fixes. |
| Overall | Acceptable |
Commentary
Test coverage / Regression check — downgrade to Acceptable. Both prescribed
uv runcommands stopped at cache initialization under read-only permissions. Using installed tools directly, lint passed and 109 tests passed, with two filesystem-dependent contract tests deselected. The complete suite collects 147 tests; its full execution was not independently verified.Documentation — downgrade to Acceptable, cosmetic only. The run spec records 145 tests, including 57 contract cases, before the final commit added two tests. Current collection contains 147 total / 59 contract cases. Append a final-commit verification result to distinguish the earlier run from the completed change.
Regression check — no additional downgrade. The submission log remains header-only, and the reported scratch TSV was deleted, so that smoke run cannot be independently inspected. The run spec explicitly names the training-data blocker, satisfying the audit’s blocker exception. No scoring/writer implementation changed, and no submitted-TSV overwrite was found in the inspected evidence.